All Rums by Rating
Every rum is given a rating from 0-100 based on my own rating system.
A variation or difference of a few points is hardly definitive, so please consider ratings accordingly.
| RUM | TYPE | COUNTRY | RATING |
| Angostura 1919 ♦ | Dark | Trinidad | |
| Gosling's Family Reserve Old Rum ♦ | Dark | Bermuda | |
| Mount Gay XO ♦ | Dark | Barbados | |
| Pyrat XO Reserve ♦ ♦ | Dark | Anguilla | |
| Havana Club Añejo Blanco ♦ | White | Cuba | |
| Ron Matusalem Gran Reserva ♦ | Dark | Dominican Republic | |
| Dulseda | Cream | Caribbean (General) | |
| Cockspur 12 | Dark | Barbados | |
| Doorly's XO | Dark | Barbados | |
| Gosling's Black Seal ♦ | Dark | Bermuda | |
| Starr African Rum | White | Mauritius (Africa) | |
| Don Q Grand Añejo Conmemorativo | Dark | Puerto Rico | |
| 10 Cane | Cane, White | Trinidad & Tobago | |
| Brugal Añejo | Gold | Dominican Republic | |
| Flor de Caña Gold | Gold | Nicaragua | |
| Captain Morgan Tattoo ♦ | Spiced | Puerto Rico | |
| Malibu Passion Fruit ♦ | Infused | Barbados | |
| Captain Morgan Spiced | Spiced | Puerto Rico | |
| Cruzan Estate Dark | Gold | St. Croix (USVI) | |
| Cruzan Banana | Infused | St. Croix (USVI) | |
| Bacardi Razz | Infused | Puerto Rico | |
| Three Palms Spiced | Spiced | Barbados | |
| Bacardi Gold | Gold | Puerto Rico | |
| Bacardi Select | Dark | Puerto Rico | |
| Bacardi Island Breeze Wild Berry | Infused | Puerto Rico | |
| Pitú Cachaça | Cane, White | Brazil |